Welcome to Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave.
At Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave., the heart of Williamsburg, NYC vibrates with the aroma of freshly baked bagels. Established in a bustling neighborhood, this beloved eatery specializes in crafting plump, flavorful bagels, including the highly praised everything bagel paired with luscious scallion cream cheese. Diners enjoy a delightful variety of breakfast options, like the hearty Meat Lovers Omelette, made with quality ingredients that resonate with New Yorkers' cravings for a satisfying meal. With friendly service that keeps patrons coming back, Bagelsmith stands out as a must-visit gem, especially for late-night bagel lovers seeking comfort and quality in every bite.
-
189 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211 Hotline: (914) 247-4953
Discovering Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave.
Nestled in the vibrant hub of Williamsburg, Bagelsmith - Bedford Ave. is a beloved bagel shop that serves as a culinary beacon for both locals and visitors. Located at 189 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, it has become a staple for anyone seeking delicious bagels and hearty sandwiches in the heart of this dynamic neighborhood.
What sets Bagelsmith apart? It offers a delightful range of freshly baked bagels, including the popular everything bagel, which has earned rave reviews from satisfied customers. As Ericka S. aptly advises, it’s the perfect stop for a bagel fix before hopping on the L train back to Manhattan, especially for those late-night cravings.
Menu Highlights
- Hot Sandwiches: Try the Grilled Chicken Sandwich or the comforting Grilled Eggplant Sandwich if you're in the mood for something hearty and satisfying.
- Breakfast Selections: The Three Cheese Omelette, made with cheddar, Swiss, and Monterey Jack, is a hearty morning choice. For a lighter option, the Egg on a Bagel Sandwich allows for endless customization.
- Cold Sandwiches: Create your own with the Build Your Own Sandwich option—just 5.50!
Customer reviews reflect not just the quality of the food but also the warmth of the service. Dipali G. raved about the enormous and filling everything bagel paired with scallion cream cheese, while Yulia B. enjoyed a whole wheat everything bagel topped with omelette and avocado, noting the popularity of the spot and its limited seating capacity—it's best to arrive early! The delightful atmosphere, complemented by friendly staff members, enhances the overall dining experience. Joi B. shares a charming anecdote about a particularly friendly employee, illustrating the welcoming environment that Bagelsmith fosters.
In every bite of their bagels and every sip of their coffee, you can taste the passion and care that goes into their food. If you're ever wandering the streets of Williamsburg, make sure to stop by Bagelsmith - a place where tradition meets flavor, making every meal memorable.
For more information or to place an order, you can reach them at (914) 247-4953. Whether you’re craving a late-night snack, a comforting breakfast, or a filling lunch, Bagelsmith is your go-to destination. Don’t miss out on this gem of Brooklyn!
Best advice: Make Bagelsmith your last stop and grab some bagels before entering the L train station on your way back to Manhattan. Chances are good this will likely be the only bagel shop open all hours of the night. One thing I miss about no longer living in NYC or visiting there less frequently these days are the bagel shops, especially Bagelsmith...because it was kind of a rare treat given its location in Williamsburg. I never came here expecting the same quality as H&H, for example, but being an everything bagel kind of person, I always found their bagels to be good. In my opinion, the service here has always been good, and that is one of the reasons I kept returning.
I got the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and was very happy! The bagels are large and extremely filling. There are several options to choose from
This place is definitely popular and I see why! I got a whole wheat everything bagel with omelette and avocado and it was delicious! There's only a few seats inside so you have to come early if you want to get a seat. They also have a wide selection of cold drinks and barbells protein bars.
Bagelsmith has come a long long way from its early days back in the late 'aughts when The Bagel Shop was the mainstay on the Northside (does anyone say "the Northside" anymore?). I remember thinking I'd only come here if the line at the other place was out the door on a weekend morning, because the Bagel Shop had better bagels with more seeds and more non dairy CC options. The other evening, I was fiending for a bagel and popped in here for an everything pumpernickel with olive tofu CC. The guy working behind the counter had to be one of the friendliest people I've ever encountered in Williamsburg! Like so friendly, I'd want to hang out in the store and chat with him and I never want to hang around in stores and chat with strangers. My bagel was perfect, with just the right amount of everything and just the right amount of CC. I did the New York thing that I don't do anywhere else and took a stroll on the cold streets feeding my face and window shopping. It was good.